Water Pump Failure - Polo 1.6 TDI 2012
Posted: Thu Mar 23, 2017 11:13 am
Hey Guys,
It has been a while since my last post! Hope everyone is doing well.
I just had a question regarding replacement of my water pump due to failure and coolant leakage and so here is the story in a nutshell:
Vehicle Details
Polo 1.6 TDI Comfortline (2012)
75 000km mileage.
I was losing water on my water bottle over the course of about a week to below minimum levels and had the vehicle serviced last week with NTT VW, and they have come back saying that the water pump is failing and leaking over the cam belt and recommend replacement of the cam belt, tensioners, and water pump. They have recommended all to be replaced as the coolant can have damaging/weakening effects on the cam belt over time, and can cause the belt to snap, bringing much higher repair cost!
Now they have quoted almost R10500 for the job which is quite high and have sourced other quotes as low as only R7500. Now my question is, what in totality (parts) is needed for this replacement job? VW have only quoted on Cam Belt, Tensioners, and Water Pump which is fine and well, but the alternative quotes came back with a 'Timing Belt Kit' which supposedly includes cam belt, tensioners, idlers etc. (a few additional parts). Now the cost of this kit is over double VW's quoted cam belt and tensioner quote and the alternative have said that VW normally only quote on these two items and when working on the vehicle will phone and say that additional parts are needed and will add to the total bill!? Now I am unsure of the truth in this as I am unsure of what all is needed in this kind of replacement.
Has anyone been through this process before and what is recommended when doing this sort of replacement looking at possible problems to be avoided down the line?
It has been a while since my last post! Hope everyone is doing well.
I just had a question regarding replacement of my water pump due to failure and coolant leakage and so here is the story in a nutshell:
Vehicle Details
Polo 1.6 TDI Comfortline (2012)
75 000km mileage.
I was losing water on my water bottle over the course of about a week to below minimum levels and had the vehicle serviced last week with NTT VW, and they have come back saying that the water pump is failing and leaking over the cam belt and recommend replacement of the cam belt, tensioners, and water pump. They have recommended all to be replaced as the coolant can have damaging/weakening effects on the cam belt over time, and can cause the belt to snap, bringing much higher repair cost!
Now they have quoted almost R10500 for the job which is quite high and have sourced other quotes as low as only R7500. Now my question is, what in totality (parts) is needed for this replacement job? VW have only quoted on Cam Belt, Tensioners, and Water Pump which is fine and well, but the alternative quotes came back with a 'Timing Belt Kit' which supposedly includes cam belt, tensioners, idlers etc. (a few additional parts). Now the cost of this kit is over double VW's quoted cam belt and tensioner quote and the alternative have said that VW normally only quote on these two items and when working on the vehicle will phone and say that additional parts are needed and will add to the total bill!? Now I am unsure of the truth in this as I am unsure of what all is needed in this kind of replacement.
Has anyone been through this process before and what is recommended when doing this sort of replacement looking at possible problems to be avoided down the line?